November 19, 2026
In October 2026, the typical Jamaica Plain condo that sold went under agreement in 7 days, down from 16 days in October 2025, according to the Boston Real Estate Observer's October report. Half of those condos sold at or above their first asking price, compared with 39% a year earlier. On the Observer's live Jamaica Plain page, the count as of November 15 was 96 homes for sale, and 48% of them had already cut their asking price.
Price per square foot connects those two figures. This year, the condos that went under agreement were listed at an average of about $640 a foot, while the condos still for sale are asking about $40 a foot more. If you're comparing Jamaica Plain with other neighborhoods this winter, which side of that line a listing falls on tells you more than the median price does.
MLS figures for Jamaica Plain condos, year to date through October 28, 2026, show the split directly. Condos that went under agreement this year were listed at an average of $642 a square foot. Condos that closed sold for an average of $641 a square foot. Condos still for sale on October 28 were asking an average of $681 a square foot.
| Jamaica Plain condos, 2026 through Oct. 28 | Average price per sq ft |
|---|---|
| List price of units that went under agreement | $642 |
| Sale price of units that closed | $641 |
| List price of units still for sale on Oct. 28 | $681 |
| Original list price of units that later cut their price | $676 |
What buyers paid matched what was asked on the units that sold, so buyers aren't negotiating everything down. The gap sits with the listings still on the market, which are asking about 6% more per foot on average. On an 1,100-square-foot two-bedroom, the difference between $681 and $641 a foot comes to about $44,000, roughly $749,000 asked against $705,000 paid.
Over the past 12 months, the Observer puts the middle half of Jamaica Plain condo sales between $568 and $716 a square foot, with a typical $639. The average unsold listing is therefore asking a price that only the top quarter or so of closed sales reached. Some listings justify it with a renovated kitchen, parking, outdoor space or a top-floor unit near the Pond. Many sellers are pricing as if every listing does.
The inventory numbers look like a market turning toward buyers. Active condo listings stood at 84 on October 28, up from 62 a year earlier and 47 in 2023. At this year's pace, that's 3.79 months of supply, the highest in the five years shown. The comparable figure was 1.80 in 2022 and 2.60 in 2025. By October 28, 133 condo listings had changed their price this year. That is the most in any of those five years, against 109 in 2025 and 73 in 2024.
Demand hasn't fallen off. This year 265 condos went under agreement through October 28, compared with 254 over the same stretch of 2025. New listings rose more, to 402 from 366. Buyers are taking about as many condos as before, and the listings left over are asking an average of $681 a foot.
The Massachusetts Association of Realtors' October 2026 figures support this reading. They show 21 Jamaica Plain condo sales at an $810,000 median, with 74 condos for sale, 8.8% more than a year earlier. MAR's September table had 16 sales at a $758,750 median. With samples that small, a few top-floor units can move the median by $50,000 in a month. Price per square foot gives a steadier read. On that measure, the Observer's October condo figure of $629 was a little under the $654 recorded in October 2025.
Pricing also slipped in late summer and then recovered. For all home types, the Observer shows the typical sale reaching 101.4% of first asking in May 2026, falling to 95.7% in September, and returning to 100.0% in October.
Lots of new construction might seem like a natural explanation for the inventory. In Jamaica Plain, most of the new construction is rental housing, and much of it is income-restricted. The Boston Housing Authority finished Mildred C. Hailey Phase I in June 2026, with 223 affordable rental homes at 2 and 6 Lamartine Street beside Jackson Square. The city announced the start of construction on 127 Amory Street, a 96-unit income-restricted building, in August 2025. Near Forest Hills, Arx Urban's 294 Hyde Park Avenue will add 48 mixed-income rental homes, according to the city. The eight acres along Washington Street at Arborway Yard have been set aside for community development under the MBTA's revised bus-garage plan, the Jamaica Plain Gazette reported, but the plan gives no housing count or schedule for that land.
The new for-sale condos are few, and they're priced well above the median. In Stonybrook, Watermark Development's project at the former Doyle's Cafe has three buildings. The Jamaica Plain Gazette described them as a five-story, 16-condo building with ground-floor retail at 3478–3484 Washington St., now called One Gartland, plus seven condos at 60 Williams Street and six at 69 Williams Street. The project's sales site lists both Williams Street buildings as sold out, with starting prices of $1,249,000 and $1,325,000. It lists One Gartland as coming soon, with December 2026 availability and a starting price of $1,199,000. In March 2025, MassLive reported a projected starting price of $1.35 million for One Gartland. The current starting price is about $150,000 lower.
The largest for-sale proposal is 920 Centre St., the former Poor Clare monastery at Murray Circle next to the Arnold Arboretum. The plan calls for 79 market-rate condos and 79 apartments. Its designer told the neighborhood council the condos are aimed at long-time Jamaica Plain residents who want to downsize without leaving, according to the Gazette. The condo mix is 49% one-bedrooms, 46% two-bedrooms and 5% three-bedrooms. It's still a proposal in its fourth year of community discussion, so it isn't part of this winter's choices.
With so few new for-sale condos coming to market, new construction accounts for little of the 84 active listings. If a seller is asking $681 a foot for a walk-up conversion while new construction a mile away starts at $1.2 million, that seller is competing with nearby conversions, which have gone under agreement at an average of about $640 a foot this year.
Your first step is to divide the asking price by the square footage and compare it with $640. Then check how long the listing has been on the market.
The neighborhood stands up well against the rest of the city at these prices. Over the past 12 months, the typical Jamaica Plain condo sold for $639 a square foot, 21% below the Boston-wide $811. For a buyer coming from a costlier part of the city, a well-priced Jamaica Plain condo is reasonable value. The overpriced listings are reaching for South End prices without the same features.
Is Jamaica Plain a buyer's market now? No. The Observer classifies it as a seller's market at about 3.1 months of supply, based on the past 12 weeks of accepted offers, as of November 15. MLS condo data through October 28 shows 3.79 months. Both figures are below the four-month mark where the Observer starts calling a market balanced. On average, the listings making up that supply are asking about $40 a foot more than buyers have been paying.
Will One Gartland pull prices up for older condos nearby? It's at a different price point. A $1,199,000 starting price for new elevator-building condos with garage parking sets a ceiling for new construction near Stonybrook. It doesn't set the price of a typical resale unit, which has been closing at about $640 a foot.
Does winter change the math? Fewer homes sell in winter. Counting all home types, the Observer recorded 16 to 22 Jamaica Plain sales a month from December 2025 through March 2026, compared with 44 to 54 a month from May through July 2026 and 36 in August. A listing that sits through December above the line usually faces a decision on price before the spring listings arrive.
Whether you're comparing a fresh listing on Centre Street with one that has been cut twice near Forest Hills, or trying to price your own condo so it lands on the right side of $640, the per-foot math is where I start. Send the units you're weighing to Jamie Iacoi and we'll go through that math together. You can also read more on the Jamaica Plain neighborhood page or the buyer resources. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today so I can guide you through the buying and selling process.